Lobster Roll Recipe

There’s something so wonderfully indulgent about a lobster roll. Maybe it’s the luxurious feel of the lobster meat, tender and buttery, or the way it perfectly contrasts with a warm, toasted bun. Every time I make lobster rolls, I’m reminded of summers by the coast, where the ocean breeze pairs perfectly with the rich flavors of fresh seafood. This recipe is a simple yet satisfying version of the classic New England lobster roll, designed to bring that vacation vibe straight to your kitchen, no matter where you are. Let’s dive into the details, and I promise, you’ll be dreaming of seaside escapes with every bite!

this RECIPE

Why these lobster rolls will win you over 🦞

Okay, so let’s talk about why these lobster rolls are worth your time. First off, they’re incredibly easy to make, despite how fancy lobster sounds. You only need a few fresh ingredients, and with minimal prep, you’ll be serving up restaurant-quality rolls at home. The buttery lobster paired with herbs like chives and dill creates a flavor combo that’s simple yet decadent. And the soft, slightly toasted buns? They’re the perfect vessel to hold it all together without overshadowing the star of the show—the lobster, of course!

The first time I made lobster rolls…

I still remember the first time I made lobster rolls at home. I’d just come back from a summer trip to Maine, where I ate lobster rolls almost every other day. The craving followed me back home, and I was determined to recreate that magic in my own kitchen. Now, I’ll admit, I was nervous at first—working with lobster can seem intimidating. But once I got started, I realized how simple it can be. The smell of melted butter mixing with fresh herbs as I tossed everything together brought me right back to that little seafood shack by the water. And when I took that first bite? Let’s just say it tasted like a mini vacation.

Lobster roll origins: a quick dive into history

The lobster roll has its roots in New England, with some claiming its birthplace to be Connecticut, while others argue for Maine. The Connecticut version is usually served warm with butter, while the Maine version often comes chilled with a light mayo dressing. While the specifics vary from town to town, one thing’s for sure—lobster rolls have been a beloved staple of coastal cuisine for decades. What’s interesting is that back in the 19th century, lobster was considered “poor man’s food” and fed to prisoners. Oh, how times have changed! Today, lobster is considered a delicacy, and these rolls are a true treat for seafood lovers.

Let’s talk ingredients: the heart of this dish

Lobster: the star of the show

The lobster is obviously the centerpiece here. You’ll need around 3 cups of cooked, chopped lobster meat—about 7-8 4-ounce tails. If you’re not up for dealing with live lobsters, many grocery stores sell pre-cooked lobster tails, which can be a huge time-saver. If you ever find yourself short on lobster, you could substitute with shrimp, but really, nothing beats the richness of lobster meat in this dish. Lobster is also a great source of lean protein, along with vitamins like B12 and minerals such as zinc and copper. So, it’s delicious and nutritious—win-win!

Butter: because butter makes everything better

In this recipe, you’re using melted butter to coat the lobster and to brush on the buns before toasting. If you’re trying to make the dish a little lighter, you could swap out the butter for a drizzle of olive oil, but in my experience, nothing gives the same luxurious flavor that butter does. After all, we’re going for that rich, seaside flavor, and butter helps bring that to life.

Fresh herbs: chives and dill

Chives and dill add a refreshing burst of flavor that balances out the richness of the lobster and butter. They’re what give this dish that light, summery touch. If you don’t have fresh chives or dill, you can use dried versions, though I highly recommend fresh if you can swing it. You could also experiment with tarragon, which has a slightly sweet, anise-like flavor.

Lemon juice: bright and zesty

A squeeze of lemon juice adds the perfect pop of acidity, brightening up the dish. It’s the kind of ingredient that makes you go, “Oh, that’s what was missing!” when you taste it. If you’re out of lemons, lime juice can work in a pinch, but the flavor will be a bit sharper.

Soft buns: the cozy vessel

We’re using soft, hotdog-style buns here, which are perfect for holding all that buttery lobster. New England-style buns, which are flat on the sides and designed to be split-top, are traditional if you can find them. But any soft, slightly sweet bun will do the trick. Just make sure to toast them with a bit of butter for that extra crunch and flavor.

Kitchen gear: what you need (and what you can totally skip)

To make these lobster rolls, you don’t need much in the way of fancy kitchen gear. A sharp knife for chopping the lobster is essential, and a good mixing bowl to toss everything together is helpful. If you don’t have a pastry brush for buttering the buns, you can use a spoon or even your fingers to get the job done. And if you don’t want to toast your buns in the oven, a quick sear in a pan on the stovetop works too. Keeping it simple is the name of the game here.

Step-by-step: crafting the perfect lobster roll

1. Prepare the lobster meat
   Whether you’re cooking the lobster from scratch or using pre-cooked tails, make sure to chop the lobster into bite-sized chunks. You want pieces that are small enough to fit in a roll but big enough to give that satisfying bite.
2. Mix it up
   In a large bowl, toss the chopped lobster with the melted butter, chives, dill, salt, pepper, and a squeeze of lemon juice. Give it a taste and adjust the seasoning as needed. If it’s your first time making lobster rolls, don’t be afraid to tweak it—maybe a little more lemon or an extra pinch of dill?
3. Toast the buns
   Brush the insides of your buns with melted butter and pop them into a 350°F oven for 4-5 minutes. Keep an eye on them; you’re looking for a light golden toast, not crispy. You could also toast the buns in a skillet for a bit more control. If you’re short on time, I’ve even tossed them in a toaster oven—it works just fine!
4. Assemble and serve
   Spoon the warm lobster mixture into the toasted buns and sprinkle with a few extra chives. Serve immediately while everything is warm and buttery.

Variations and tweaks you can try

Want to make it gluten-free?

Easy! Just swap out the regular buns for your favorite gluten-free hotdog rolls. I’ve done this with gluten-free brioche buns before, and they were just as delicious.

Craving a bit of spice?

Add a pinch of cayenne pepper or a few dashes of hot sauce to the lobster mixture for a bit of heat. It’s an unexpected twist that adds depth without overpowering the fresh lobster flavor.

Seasonal switch-ups

In the summer, these lobster rolls are perfect as-is, but in the colder months, you could try adding a pinch of warm spices like smoked paprika to give the dish a cozier feel.

Going for a lighter version?

If you want to cut down on the butter, try mixing the lobster with a little olive oil and Greek yogurt. It gives the same creamy feel with a bit more lightness.

How to serve these lobster rolls in style

When it comes to serving lobster rolls, keep it casual but thoughtful. I love to plate them on a rustic wooden board, with a side of kettle chips or a light, zesty slaw. Garnish the rolls with a few extra herbs, and maybe even a lemon wedge on the side for those who like an extra squeeze of citrus. If you’re feeling fancy, a sprinkle of flaky sea salt over the top of the rolls adds a touch of texture and elevates the whole experience.

drink pairings: refreshing and light

For these buttery, herb-filled lobster rolls, I love pairing them with crisp, light drinks. An iced lemonade with a hint of mint works beautifully, cutting through the richness of the lobster. A sparkling water with a squeeze of lime is another go-to—it’s refreshing and doesn’t overpower the flavors. If you’re a fan of iced tea, a light, unsweetened black tea with a splash of peach syrup adds a summery twist that complements the lobster perfectly.

Storage and reheating tips

Lobster rolls are best enjoyed fresh, but if you happen to have leftovers (lucky you!), store the lobster mixture separately from the buns in an airtight container in the fridge. The lobster can last up to two days. When reheating, I recommend warming the lobster mixture gently in a pan over low heat with a little extra butter to keep it moist. As for the buns, just pop them back in the oven or give them a quick toast in a skillet. Avoid microwaving the lobster, as it can become rubbery.

Adjusting for different serving sizes

This recipe makes about four lobster rolls, but it’s easy to scale up if you’re feeding a crowd. If doubling the recipe, just be sure to add the butter and herbs incrementally—start with less and add more to taste. The balance of flavors is key, so you don’t want to overdo it all at once. If you’re making fewer rolls, cut down the lobster, but keep a generous amount of butter to avoid any dryness.

Troubleshooting potential hiccups

If you find that your lobster rolls taste a little bland, don’t hesitate to add more salt or lemon juice. Sometimes lobster can vary in flavor, and a little extra seasoning can bring everything back to life. If the rolls come out too dry, it could be because the lobster wasn’t coated well enough in butter—just toss it again with a little more before serving.

Ready to make your own lobster rolls?

These lobster rolls are so easy to customize and adapt, making them the perfect dish for a cozy meal or an impressive party appetizer. Whether you’re a seafood lover or new to cooking lobster, I hope this recipe helps you discover just how simple and delicious homemade lobster rolls can be. Give it a try, and feel free to make it your own by tweaking the herbs or experimenting with different toppings. I can’t wait for you to taste it!

Frequently asked questions

Can I use frozen lobster tails?
Absolutely! Just be sure to thaw them completely before cooking, and they’ll work just as well as fresh lobster.

What can I use instead of chives and dill?
Tarragon or parsley are great alternatives. Both herbs will still give that fresh, green flavor you want in a lobster roll.

Can I make the lobster mixture ahead of time?
Yes, you can make the lobster mixture a few hours ahead and store it in the fridge. Just be sure to warm it up gently before serving.

What type of buns are best?
Soft hotdog buns or split-top New England-style rolls are ideal. You want something that will hold the lobster without overpowering the flavor.

How do I avoid overcooking lobster?
Cook the lobster just until the meat turns opaque and firm, then remove it from the heat. Overcooked lobster can turn rubbery, so keep a close eye on it!

Print